On January 9, 2025, the National Cathedral in Washington, D.C., was enveloped in a somber atmosphere as individuals gathered to pay tribute to former President Jimmy Carter. At the age of 100, Carter had established a legacy unparalleled in American history as the longest-living former president. However, the memorial service became a topic of debate for reasons extending beyond his remarkable contributions to public service.

Close friends Garth Brooks and Trisha Yearwood performed John Lennon’s 1971 anthem “Imagine” during the ceremony. While their sincere intentions were evident, the selection of the song ignited controversy on social media. Numerous fans criticized the lyrics, particularly phrases such as “Imagine there’s no heaven… Above us only sky,” deeming them unsuitable for a Christian funeral held in a historic cathedral.

Some attendees and viewers voiced their dissatisfaction, with one individual remarking, “At a devout Christian’s funeral, singing this is tone-deaf.” Others questioned the compatibility of the song with Carter’s faith, labeling it disrespectful. The criticisms encompassed both the song’s message and the performance itself, with comments regarding its delivery.

In spite of the negative feedback, a segment of the audience appreciated the gesture. Supporters defended the performance as a heartfelt homage, highlighting the emotional bond between the performers and the late president. Brooks and Yearwood shared a long-standing friendship with the Carters, frequently collaborating on charitable initiatives, particularly with Habitat for Humanity. For them, “Imagine” represented more than mere lyrics; it embodied Carter’s aspirations for unity and peace.

Jimmy Carter had frequently expressed his admiration for Lennon’s “Imagine,” reflecting on its worldwide influence. For Carter, the song transcended cultural barriers, presenting a vision of a more harmonious world. In interviews, he referred to it as a “national anthem” in regions like Cuba, where Lennon’s legacy holds significant resonance. Although the song’s message may be contentious for some, it aligned with Carter’s commitment to bridging divides and promoting understanding.

Brooks and Yearwood’s relationship with the Carters transcended mere friendship. They collaborated extensively on various Habitat for Humanity initiatives, contributing to the construction of homes for families in need. Their respect for Carter’s commitment to service and his humility was frequently expressed through public acknowledgments. On the occasion of Carter’s 100th birthday in 2024, they praised his lifelong efforts to enhance the lives of others, referring to him as a lasting source of inspiration.

Following the passing of Rosalynn Carter in late 2023, both Brooks and Yearwood were present at her memorial, offering support to Carter during his time of sorrow. Brooks later remarked on Carter’s remarkable resilience, emphasizing his capacity to inspire others even as his health waned. The couple’s bond with the Carters was firmly established on a foundation of mutual respect and shared principles.

The performance of “Imagine” may have elicited mixed reactions, yet it highlighted Carter’s profound influence on those who knew him. For Brooks and Yearwood, it served as a tribute to a man who championed the vision of a more harmonious world. While opinions on the song’s appropriateness may vary, the tribute underscored Carter’s enduring legacy of service, love, and hope—an enduring legacy that continues to motivate others.